Open vs closed kitchen: Which layout is perfect for your home?

Closed Kitchen Design

What is a closed kitchen?

Here’s a concept we are all quite familiar with. Closed layouts are usually the norm with Indian kitchen design. With this layout, the kitchen is a room unto itself which a lot of people prefer as it lends privacy. However, the renovation costs of later changing a closed kitchen to an open layout are very high.

Pros

1. This layout can make optimum use of space for drawers, cabinets and counters. A closed kitchen has more storage and work surfaces.
   
   
2. With the option to cut off the kitchen, heat, noises and smells from cooking don’t percolate to other parts of the house.
   
   
3. Cooking and related activities turn into a more private affair. The kitchen, which can become quite messy when in use, isn’t always on display to guests.

Cons

1.  A closed kitchen doesn’t have as much natural light and ventilation as an open kitchen design.
   
   
2.  Indian kitchen designs in smaller apartments may not be big enough to accommodate features like an island.
   
   
3.  This layout can make the house look smaller as the walls create physical and visual barriers. 

What is an open kitchen?

Open layouts are becoming more popular with Indian kitchen design. With this layout, the kitchen is essentially open from one or more sides, typically connected with the living or dining room or even a combined living and dining area. Usually, an open kitchen does away with one partitioning wall, sometimes in favour of a kitchen island or breakfast nook.

The pros and cons of an open kitchen layout

Pros

1.  An open kitchen design works well for both large and small spaces.
   
   
2.  With smaller homes, this layout opens up the main living area, making the room look bigger.
   
   
3.  Doing away with at least one wall makes the kitchen bright and well-ventilated.
   
   
4.  The person who is cooking can always be a part of what’s going on in the dining and/or living room.
   

Cons

1.  With an open kitchen design, everything in the kitchen is on display – both the good and the bad. This means always keeping it tidy.
   
   
2.  Noises from appliances (like the blender), heat and cooking aromas carry over very easily to the rest of the house.
   
   
3.  With at least one wall missing, the storage and work areas are substantially reduced.
   
   
4.  The cooling from the air conditioner carries over to the kitchen area, reducing its efficiency. 

1.  Instead of completely closing off the kitchen, consider semi see-through partitions like glass doors, wood slats, decorative jaali or metal panels as seen here. This can lend enough privacy when required but still keep the space airy and well-lit. A design that allows for these partitions to slide open and shut when need be, works even better. 

2.   Instead of opening the kitchen to the rest of the house, connect it with the outdoor spaces. Here, the kitchen opens out on to a balcony area which can double as an informal eating area as well. A patio or large balcony can also have a barbeque or grill. With this design, privacy is maintained yet the kitchen is well ventilated and receives a lot of natural light. Additionally, noises and smells from the kitchen don’t travel as much to the rest of the home. 

3.  If the kitchen is large enough, consider adding a small eating area within the kitchen itself. A cosy dining set allows eating and cooking to be shared activities even with a closed kitchen layout.  You could also consider a semi-open layout where instead of getting rid of one entire wall, you only open up the top half. With this you can keep counter space and the area below it while getting rid of the top half of the wall. You retain counter and storage space, can create a cosy eating area and open up the kitchen as well.